
The were the words heard round the world- or at least where TV sets were tuned in to the Miss USA pageant. When Miss California Carrie Prejean announced to viewers that "marriage is between a man and a woman," she unwittingly walked onto the set in a socio-political theatrical production that has now cast her as the Joan of Arc of conservatism. To anti-gay marriage commentators, the fact that she stammered with awkward phrases like "opposite marriage" didn't detract from the poise required of contestants. Oddly enough, it was a characteristic that drew empathy to the 21-year old San Diegan now being hailed as a victim of political correctness that lost her crown because of liberals who couldn't handle her beliefs.
I was surprised that gossip columnist Perez Hilton was on the judging panel, for his usual lack of decorum was at odds with the dignity of the event (and sadly, his post-pageant antics and name-calling bore it out). Hilton's reputation was the perfect ammo for conspiracy theories about liberal attempts to "politicize" the contest, but his query to the blonde invoked a legitimate social issue that has gained prominence during the last year. From California to Vermont, the gay marriage debate has become a current event that, like taxpayer-funded bailouts, requires awareness- even (gasp!) from beauty queens. That's why pageant officials approved the question long before Perez Hilton opened his mouth that night. Contestants were expected to be articulate and aware of civic issues, and Prejean was no exception.
In the ensuing political theater, Miss Prejean's belief in the superiority of "opposite marriage" was re-cast into a courageous stand against liberal morality. Not so fast. The girl hailed from a state that passed Proposition 8, where her stance reigns supreme (at least, for the time being). It is also a viewpoint that is consistent with the U.S. majority, and therefore a "safe" one to articulate before the general public- just as the winner's opposition to bailouts. How is it that a 21-year-old who voices the status quo morphs into a heroic symbol of courage overnight? The intrigue of her metamorphosis intensified as Prejean bemoaned how the question cost her the crown, used the inflammatory buzz phrase "politically correct," and claimed to Matt Lauer, "I feel like I'm the winner. I really do."
While I'm glad Carrie Prejean voiced her honest opinion instead of hemming and hawing like a politician, I can't hail the pouting beauty as a hero or victim in the cultural wars. She wasn't denied her freedom of speech, as some chest thumpers claim, and she wasn't a martyr. The real martyrs in this debate aren't the ladies who are unable to wear a precious tiara. It's folks like 11-year-olds Jaheem Herrera and Carl Joseph Walker-Hoover, who committed suicide after anti-gay bullying...15-year-old Lawrence King, shot in his classroom by a homophobic bully. I'm sure that Miss Prejean would condemn these atrocities with the requisite concern and sorrow befitting her stature. Yet, try as she might, she can't make a connection between these dead youth and the televised images of a defensive blonde beauty queen who boasts gay friends but doesn't think they deserve the privileges she herself enjoys...because well, "no offense to anyone out there, but that's how I've been raised." Were those kids alive, they'd see their tormenters' philosophy mirrored on their television by Miss California. Sure, her glossed lips might not form tasteless words like "faggot," but they form words that minimize the dignity and equality of the same group for which the slur is a battering ram. So.. honest conservative yes, but Joan of Arc she ain't.
Face it. Twenty years ago, an opposite response to Hilton's question (i.e., one supporting gay marriage) would've cost her the crown, and current supporters would've applauded her loss as FOX News blared, "Pro-Gay Activist Loses Beauty Crown." I won't even touch what the climate would've been like had the question addressed inter-racial marriage instead. Unfortunately for Prejean, the question was posed at a juncture when the cultural status quo is inching its way towards a holistic concept of civil rights- as well as the pageant itself. Several officials associated with the Miss USA and Miss California pageants have emphasized the concept that Miss USA is to represent all Americans, gay and straight. Sorry, Miss Prejean, that's an idea whose time has come. Finally.